• Question: have u ever felt like u could've helped someone but didn't?

    Asked by anon-215665 to Laura, Kathryn, Ian, Chris, Bogdana, Alex on 18 Jun 2019.
    • Photo: Laura Fisk

      Laura Fisk answered on 18 Jun 2019:


      Yeah, all the time unfortunately. I’m mainly thinking about all the times I walk past somebody who seems to be homeless. I always try to acknowledge them and treat them as a human being, but whether to give money to everyone is a complex issue – there’s discussion as to whether it does help the person etc. But it is really difficult and I feel it every time – by ‘it’ I mean guilt, which in psychology terms is ‘when you feel like you’ve broken a rule or value you have’.
                 ‎‏‪‫‬‭‮ ‬‬‬‬
      It might not be fair or realistic to be able to help everyone, but ‘help everyone you can’ is a rule I do have for myself, and so on some level I am breaking it – so my guilt is justified. AT the same time, I simply don’t have all the money that’s needed. SO what I try to do is donate to charities, and engage with the politics of what leads to people being homeless. We need to fix that, and we need to fix it on a ‘bigger’ level than just the individual. But at the same time, the individual matters and they don’t know I might be doing that stuff ‘behind the scenes’ – and they probably wouldn’t care that much, given that as Maslow’s hierarchy of needs suggests, if our basic needs aren’t met then we have less ‘room’ to think beyond that – that kind of thinking is a luxury we can get into when we’ve got wnough food to eat, somewhere safe to be etc etc. So it’d be completely fair (I’d actually say essential) for someone to be like, ‘You’re not helping me, now – so what’s the point?”.
                 ‎‏‪‫‬‭‮ ‬‬‬‬
      So yeah, I definitely have felt like I could have helped someone but didn’t

    • Photo: Ian Cookson

      Ian Cookson answered on 18 Jun 2019:


      Yes, my younger sister had a rough time when she was younger with drugs, and the wrong crowd. I wonder if I could have done more to help, but she lived a long way away so it wasn’t easy.

    • Photo: Chris Fullwood

      Chris Fullwood answered on 18 Jun 2019:


      I think we all feel like that at times. Sometimes we don’t like to get involved in other people’s lives because we might be worried that they’d interpret it the wrong way, being helpful might seem altruistic and nice from our perspective, but others might perceive it as patronizing. I think there are also times that even with the best will in the world, we might not have the ability to help someone because the issues they are facing might be beyond our control. Sometimes just being there to listen to someone is all the help they need

    • Photo: Alex Lloyd

      Alex Lloyd answered on 18 Jun 2019:


      With the young people I work with who have committed crimes I always ask myself if there was something more I could have done. I think this is something a lot of people experience and we all have to manage. I know some people who work with charities that go to war zones or areas with natural disasters and they speak of ‘compassion fatigue’, where you tire yourself out because you spend so much of your time looking out for other people. It’s important to help others but it’s also important to look after yourself at the same time.

    • Photo: Bogdana Huma

      Bogdana Huma answered on 19 Jun 2019:


      I often wonder about this, in relation to my students: is there something more I can help them with, do they trust me enough to feel they can come to me if they’re struggling or they need help? It’s hard to know when people don’t ask for help whether you’ve missed the opportunity to offer it, so for me it’s really important to make it clear to them that I’m available to help and that it’s okay to ask for help when you’re struggling.

Comments